I Don’t Understand What Marketing Is Working

Effective marketing has a significant impact on business growth and longevity. However, there are many ways to plan and execute a good marketing strategy – there is no one-size-fits-all formula. Therefore, it can be difficult to really understand what works for your organisation and what is wasting your time and money.
Regardless of your business size, location, industry or objectives, it is essential that your marketing plan is tailored to you. It should directly reflect your customer preferences, your business goals, your budget and the resources available to you. It should also adapt to your changing needs as you grow or as your objectives evolve.
The fluid nature of your marketing needs makes it more challenging to know exactly where you stand at any given time. As such, constant review and ongoing monitoring are crucial if you are to understand what marketing is working for you.
Get started with a marketing review
A full marketing review requires a number of steps. The first is to identify exactly what you do. This will include all your current activities, the channels you use, the messages you communicate, the audience you target, the budget you allocate, the time you spend and the results you achieve. Though it may seem like a massive project, the review can often be simplified considerably with the effective use of AI, inbuilt platform reporting systems and automation. Once set up, this can make ongoing monitoring quicker, easier and more useful to your entire team.
It is essential to have defined your marketing goals before reflecting on any data. What you measure and how you interpret success will rely heavily on these goals. For instance, if your objective is to increase sales, then you will need to look more closely at the financial data. If your goal is centred on improving brand awareness, then data demonstrating reach and engagement may provide more appropriate insights.

What marketing data is important?
When deciding which data will build an accurate representation of your current marketing strengths and weaknesses, it’s necessary to eliminate any vanity metrics. Some numbers can distort outcomes and exaggerate the success of a marketing strategy. For example, a high follower count for a specific social media account may seem positive. However, if your goal is to increase sales and your social media content has zero engagement, then even a massive following is likely to have very little – if any – impact on business revenue.
All of this emphasises the need to consider data in context and not focus on any numbers in isolation. A combination of the below would be a good starting point for most organisations:
General
- Customer acquisition cost (CAC)
- Cost per lead (CPL)
- Conversation rate
- Customer retention rate (CRR)
- Customer lifetime value (CLV)
- Churn rate
- Return on marketing investment (ROMI) – more below
Social media
- Reach
- Engagement rate
- Click-through rate (CTR)
- Follower growth rate
Paid media
- Impressions/views/reach
- CTR
- Cost per click (CPC)
- Cost per acquisition (CPA)
- Return on ad spend (ROAS)
Website
- Monthly traffic
- Traffic sources
- SEO score
- AI visibility score
- Checkout conversation rate
Email marketing/Newsletters
- Open rate
- CTR
- Placed order rate
- Revenue generated
- Unsubscribe rate
SEO/AEO
- SEO score
- Keywords ranking
- Backlinks
- AI visibility/authority scores
- AI referral mentions
- AI referrals
By establishing some of the above for your business, you will be able to identify the highest performing marketing channels for you.
You can see which activities are driving traffic to your website, whether campaigns are targeting the right people, if campaigns are generating the desired leads or sales and how much revenue each channel is bringing in.
Data-driven marketing decisions
Once you have access to the above data, you will have direct insights into how well each area of your marketing is working. This information should be used to drive all future decisions, ensuring that any changes or new marketing plans are implemented in the most effective and cost-efficient way.
Ineffective campaigns or channels should be removed from your plan or adapted to improve outcomes and better align with your marketing objectives. Activities that have performed well and delivered a strong return should be prioritised as you move forward.
And if all of this still feels overwhelming, or if you are simply looking for experts in the field to provide specialist insight and objective recommendations, we offer a comprehensive marketing audit at We Do Marketing. We will evaluate every aspect of your marketing to determine exactly which channels and campaigns are doing well for you, and which could be improved. We offer data-driven, strategic guidance with instantly actionable advice that will strengthen your marketing and business development from day one.
Discover how a Marketing Growth Audit could propel your business forward today!














